Immediately after the
TCEQ Commissioners ruled 2-1 to conduct a contested case hearing on Asarco’s
air permit renewal in April of 2004, Asarco and associations from across the
State of Texas representing 140,000 permitted facilities asked the
Commissioners to reconsider their decision. The Commissioners declined to
reconsider.
Asarco believes the
contested case hearing will be a time-consuming, costly legal proceeding
that is outside the rules outlined in the Texas air permit statutes. To
protect its investment, Asarco was compelled to file a lawsuit against TCEQ
asking the courts to rule on the legality of the contested case hearing.
Oral arguments were held on February 25, 2005. The judge ruled in
favor of the TCEQ.